Send us your questions for new Artistic Director Harry Christophers to askharry@handelandhaydn.org. Harry will answer your questions here and in upcoming program books.

Question on Future Programming

Dear Harry,

My favorite composer is Corelli. Is it possible that in the near future that you could have some of his pieces in one of your concerts?

Thank you so much for your email and I can quite understand why you love Corelli. I do hope that one day we will be able to programme some of his wonderful music. There may be a possibility in the 2012 season – I was just thinking of some of his Concerti Grossi only a few days ago.

All best,
Harry

Kudos on last season's Bach Portrait

Dear Mr Christophers:

Thank you for recent and warm letter to subscribers. The opportunity for reply allows me to express the opinion that both chorus and orchestra are performing at even finer levels of precision and co-ordination above the high standards, as a subscribers, we expect; this struck me powerfully at last spring’s Bach concert. Needless to say, you have in Boston many grateful appreciators of your brilliant recorded work with the Sixteen; you have not yet disappointed us in person!

Page Nelson

Dear Page,

So glad to know you enjoyed our finale last season, Bach Portrait, and that you received the letter from me. I appreciate your enthusiasm for my work with the orchestra and chorus. I am blessed to be a part of such a talented group and enjoy working with them. I hope to meet you at a concert soon. I thank you and Boston for the kind reception!

Best,
Harry

Praise for Catherine Wyn-Rogers

Dear Harry,

I am a season’s subscriber and have been coming to the Messiah since I was in graduate school which was more than thirty years ago. I found last night’s performance the best and the most moving of any that I have attended. And, yes, I heard “He was despis-ed” as never before. Your soloist was magnificent.

Keep up the great work.
Peter Woloschuk

Dear Peter,

Thank you for your kind words, and I quite agree that Catherine’s depiction of “He was despised” is one of the best – so moving in its intensity. I’ve had the pleasure of working and recording with her in the past and find her to be a Handelian like no other! So nice to hear from an H&H subscriber.

All Best,
Harry

Mozart: A Musical Journey Feedback

Dear Mr. Director,

It was a pleasure meeting you and Rachel Podger back stage after this past Friday's all Mozart program, thanks to the good offices of my friend Krista Buckland-Reisner.

I haven't seen it yet, but from what our mutual friend Ian Watson tells me, the Boston Globe's critic was not overly generous in the Saturday Edition's review. I want you to know, therefore, for what it's worth, that I heartily disagree with him. From my vantage point, which was 3 rows back right of center, it was a superb performance.

I wonder if he knew enough to take into account the fact that a Mozart size ensemble cannot overcome the innate limitations of a cavernous hall like Symphony Hall, which was designed for the huge orchestras and the higher pitched louder instruments that had become the fashion at the time it was built?

Ian also said that he took a side swipe at Rachel Podger's playing to the audience. I had never heard her live before Friday so I didn't know what to expect, but although I am not swayed one way or another by theatrics, in this instance, I thought her general stage presence and interaction with the both the ensemble and the audience added to her performance. One can't say for sure, but from what we know Mozart played to his audiences, and I doubt that Mr. Eichler finds fault with Joshua Bell's showmanship.

I certainly hope that this will not make it impossible for you to get Rachel back here. It is rare indeed to get to hear a player of her caliber. I doubt that you or any other really knowledgeable person would find vigorously disagree with my opinion which is she is the best at what she does, namely baroque and early classical period violin.

By the way, if you speak with her please ask her to get her own website.

Hope to see you again.

All the best,
Bill Hamilton

Dear Bill,

Thanks so much for your email. It was likewise a pleasure to meet you after the concert the other night. While we respect the various opinions of our critics, it’s you, the audience, that really matters and you were not the only one who thought Rachel’s performance was wonderful — we all did! I am hoping sometime over the next couple of seasons to get her back. Do give my very best to Ian when you see him — we go back a very long way!!!

All best,
Harry

2010-2011 Season Repertoire Inquiry

Maestro -

Please explain to me why we are doing Beethoven's Fifth? I was hoping for more of the back to baroque. Yes, Sir Roger's 6th was wonderful (the 4th, eh ?) but I fervently believe that H&H's direction should be to earlier music. There is so much of the baroque — Italian especially — that is wonderful and seldom performed. For Beethoven I'll get tickets to the BSO.

-Barry Hoffman (25+ yr. subscriber)

Dear Barry,

Thanks for getting in touch. Part of the Handel and Haydn Society’s tradition has been to create excitement with performances of works that are under-appreciated because they have become warhorses, or done too often and badly. Take my approach to Messiah, as an example. Many feel the work is overdone, but I, in earnest, try to make it fresh again every year and have converted many new and returning patrons to love the work.

My aim over the next seasons is to return to more baroque music (I must say that you for one will probably be delighted for what I have in store for you!) But still, I think it is important to maintain and build on the excellent work of both Richard Egarr and more importantly Sir Roger Norrington, particularly in his position of Artistic Advisor, have done to make us look at and listen to Beethoven’s works in a different light.

Our programming discussions with Richard Egarr (you might recall his exceptional performance of Beethoven 8 and Mozart Piano Cto 23 in November 2008?), led to his desire to re-introduce our audience to Haydn’s piano concerti (we last did the Concert in D with Thomas Dunn in 1981!) and bring the first performance of Haydn’s Symphony No. 101. We started with the concerto in D, and discovered that we had never combined Haydn with Beethoven on the same program! Given Beethoven’s relationship with Haydn, the history of the Fifth Symphony at H&H — first performed by H&H on May 22, 1857 (well before BSO was founded), 1863 and 1871; then in 1994 with Christopher Hogwood; in 2000 (Ivan Bolton) and 2006 (Grant Llewellyn). Our history with this work, coupled with the economic realities of the current world, led us to embrace Richard’s suggestion to perform Beethoven’s Fifth.

Richard Egarr is an exceptional musician and conductor and I know he will give a memorable performance of Beethoven’s Fifth on period instruments. I hope you will give this masterwork a new listen as I sincerely believe you will delight in the experience.

All best,
Harry

Messiah on DVD?

Dear Director Harry Christophers,

I just want to mention how amazing the interpretation of the Messiah was this past December. It was an unforgettable experience. I also wanted to make you a suggestion, please record the Messiah with the orchestra and chorus, because I think that would wonderful to have on record. Not that I won't attend the concert whenever I can, but to have a CD or a DVD of you guys interpreting it, as you masterfully did it last year will be a plus.

Thank you.

Best wishes,
Louis Benavides

Dear Louis,

Thank you so much for your email and I’m delighted that you enjoyed Messiah last December. We are thinking of producing a DVD of Messiah in a few years where we can capture not only the music but also the performance. Look forward to meeting you at a concert.

All the very best,
Harry

Concertmaster Transition Inquiry

Dear Mr. Christophers;

As a long time H&H subscriber, for 25 years, I am quite disturbed to discover that Dan Stepner will be leaving H&H at the end of this season. Can you please explain this very dramatic change at H&H.

Sincerely,
Stephen

Dear Stephen,

Thanks so much for writing and for sharing your thoughts on Dan's retirement. Dan has given close to 25 years of wonderful service to H&H. He feels that this would be a fitting time to retire as concertmaster and devote more time to solo and chamber performance. I am just happy that I can continue the ground breaking work Dan has done with H&H — his knowledge of period instruments and his infectious enthusiasm has been a model for all those interested in the period movement.

I am delighted that Dan has agreed to play the Bach Double and Brandenburg 5 in the final concert of the season as he says his farewell to H&H. It will be a great occasion.

As ever,
Harry

Handel's Messiah Feedback

Dear Maestro Christophers,

I am a conservatory trained singer and conductor who first saw you conduct Messiah with Handel and Haydn in December 2007 and was on the edge of my seat the entire evening. The vitality of sound which you extracted from the ensemble was truly awe inspiring. Messiah is one of my favorite works and to hear, with clarity, such nuance in the phrasing of choruses like "He Trusted in God" or the crisply defined sixteenth notes of the "Hallelujah" chorus, made me not hesitate for an instant in purchasing your ensemble's newest recording of the work. I purchased it through iTunes, and one of the unfortunate results is the lack of liner notes or credits.

For me, one of the most brilliant aspects of the recording is the continuo section you assembled. The selective use of theorbo, for instance. But, by far, the outstanding member of the section was the harpsichordist. Two particular numbers of note are the cadence of the A section in "Why do the Nations," and the flourish after the first entrance of the oboes in the "Arrival of the Queen of Sheba," which you so generously provided as supplement to an already elite album.

I realize this may seem like an absurd query to address to such a busy fellow as yourself (I apologize!). Is there any chance you would be willing to provide me with the name of said harpsichordist? I would love to hear more.

It is such a thrill and privilege to have your presence in Boston with Handel and Haydn! You have a beautiful sense of phrasing and texture and are quite an inspiration to me.

All the best,
Garrett

Dear Garrett,

Lovely to hear from you and I'm so pleased you enjoy the Messiah recording. Yes that particular harpsichordist is rather exceptional — it's Gary Cooper (not the actor!). Gary really only plays chamber and solo music now — he regularly partners the violinist, Rachel Podger (they have some fabulous discs out). The harpsichordist on "Sheba" was actually Matthew Halls, another fantastic player — he recently formed his own ensemble, Retrospect.

I have been blessed over the years with excellent continuo players, in the early days it was Paul Nicholson who is now a priest, then Laurence Cummings, who will is now very busy conducting and will be with the Handel and Haydn Society for a Valentine's Day programme soon and then it was Gary and Matt. I now use Alastair Ross who is also brilliant but they are few and far between.

By the way what's this Maestro title — please call me Harry!

All best,
Harry

Pacing in Messiah

Maestro,

Welcome back to Boston! I attended the second performance of Messiah this year and deeply enjoyed your interpretation and the talents of the performers. I look forward to many concerts with you in the next few years.

I hope my question doesn't mark me as a philistine, or suggest that I have a short attention span. Indeed, I love long symphonies and even have attended a complete Wagner Ring Cycle in standing room.

Here goes: I was struck that the Part the Second seemed to lag just a bit, especially compared to the well-paced other two sections. Since you have admitted — in a recent "Ask Harry" — that you don't stick to a particular version of Messiah, what about deleting a few movements from Part the Second? For example, one might delete the tenor recitatives and arias after the chorus "He trusted in God" as well as perhaps the chorus "Their sound is gone out."

A performance even twelve minutes shorter would seem desirable to me (or at least worth testing), and benefit both the audience and the singers. After all, there are some arias routinely cut from Mozart operas, and Shakespeare plays are rarely performed intact. What would you think about trying a slightly trimmed Messiah for next December?

Yours,
Frederick

Dear Frederick,

No way would you be marked out as a philistine! However, the tenor sequence you mention after "He trusted in God" is the crux of Messiah — no way would I ever cut those movements! The Second Part is very tricky to pace and you have made me think how I need to keep the momentum going. However, it is the Passion story and it does need time to evolve. My intention is always to make the "turba" chorus "He trusted in God" full of mockery and derision of our Lord — if the venom of the crowd is there then the tenor can really grip the audience with "Thy rebuke." I do recall a staggering amount of coughing at that point on the second night and I wonder whether that hindered the impact we were trying to get — one wants to achieve a moment of absolute stillness.

It was the first time for many years that some movements were cut — I broke with tradition — should I be marked out as a philistine!

All the best for a great New Year,
Harry

Handel and Haydn on the Radio

Kind Sir:

I just heard on satellite radio a recording of the Handel and Haydn Society singing "O Magnum Mysterium." It was a contemporary arrangement with woodwinds and a percussion player on chimes. I am sorry to say the station did not show who the composer was. Can you tell me who the composer of this beautiful arrangement was?

Thank you for you your kind attention to my request.
Louis

Dear Louis,

Sorry, this was before my time so I asked someone who does know all about it. Our music librarian, Jesse Levine, replied that "O Magnum Mysterium" was composed by Jennifer Higdon, and the work is featured on our All Is Bright recording.

All best,
Harry

Programming Question

Dear Harry,

First off many thanks for the note which I found affixed to my seat upon arrival at Viva La Voce a few weeks back. My wife and I thoroughly enjoyed the program and I would say that you’re off to an outstanding start as the Artistic Director! My wife and I wish you continued success. Our next visit will be to enjoy A Baroque Gift in December.

As to my question, I was wondering if you or the Society has ever developed a program around the natural elements? The sky, earth, water etc.? I work in the green industry as an arborist and have always been able to locate written material on these subjects be it based in folklore or science but I have always been curious how classical music might further enrich these areas and how Handel and Haydn might present such a program. It might just bring a whole other meaning to "ground rhythm." Just a suggestion!

All the best,
Chuck and Karen

Dear Chuck and Karen,

I’m delighted that you enjoyed the opening concert of the season and look forward to seeing you sometime over the next year or so.

One of our cellists, Reinmar Seidler, is particularly interested in matters green and has just been over in England doing a lecture (as part of a Handel weekend) entitled The Ecological Handel: Music, Ecology, and Science in the Pastoral Tradition.

He has based it partly on material from a paper he’s writing on Beethoven’s Pastoral Symphony where he discusses the music as constituting in certain respects a "model" ecological system. I am hoping that we might be able to include his talk in the run-up to Roger Norrington’s performances of Beethoven later in the season.

Anyway food for thought – many thanks.

All best,
Harry

Returns and Farewell Feedback

Harry Christophers:

I enjoyed the performance last night. The Piano Concerto no. 21 in C Major, K. 467 by Mozart, I enjoyed the most.

-R.L.

Dear R.L.,

I am so pleased you enjoyed the concert with Jane Glover and Robert Levin. I hope to meet you at a future performance. All of us at Handel and Haydn appreciate your support.

Best,
Harry

Compliments on Messiah

Dear Maestro,

First I want to say how thrilled I am that you are here in Boston as Artistic Director of Handel and Haydn. I have been a fan of yours (and The Sixteen) for many years, and I'm not ashamed to say that your conducting of the Messiah in Dec 2007 with Handel and Haydn was the first time I can recall myself actually crying during that piece. Something very special was brought out of the orchestra and chorus that night — extremely moving and very beautiful.

My question is more of an inquiry about one of my favorite composers. Why is it that we do not find the work of Johann Friedrich Fasch performed more often? If not as "top billing" I would think his work might make an obvious compliment to a program with his more famous contemporaries. It would be wonderful to hear his work showcased on a period-instrument orchestra.

Thanks in advance! And thanks for all you do!!

-Scott

Dear Scott,

Thank you so much for your kind e-mail and I am so pleased you enjoyed our Messiah a couple of years ago. I hope I can develop things even more this time round!

Now Fasch is a very interesting composer (I'm glad you said Johann and not Carl!) and yes, we should programme some of his music — it would probably be best in one of our Jordan Hall concerts. Everything is pretty mapped out for the 2010-2011 season but I will see what we can do!

All best and I look forward to meeting you - and please call me Harry!

Best,
Harry

Crafting Messiah

Maestro,

I was delighted with your appointment as Artistic Director of Handel and Haydn. I must confess that I had not heard of you prior to hearing you conduct Messiah two years ago. Yours was by far the best performance of Messiah of the very many that I have heard over the years (not going back all the way to 1818, but as far back as Thomas Dunn's time). Here is a small suggestion. In years past, the program notes for Handel and Haydn Messiah performances mentioned which of Handel's versions was being performed. I always follow the performance in a reduction score, and I have enjoyed annotating the variations. While it is enjoyably challenging to try to figure out which version is being performed from my annotations, I would be very happy if Handel and Haydn resumed the practice of identifying the version. Thanks very much. I very much look forward to your leadership of the Society.

-Art

Dear Art,

Thank you for your kind email and I am delighted you enjoyed our performance of Messiah a couple of years ago. Whilst it is always interesting to say one is doing a particular version of Messiah, I tend to do one that suits my own personal interpretation. Handel was always practical and most of the variants appear as a result of which singer was available to him on that particular occasion. The original Dublin performance is a very interesting version and I did conduct it in Dublin for the anniversary of the first performance there — of course the hall doesn’t exist today and that early version has no woodwind and, among other things, an extraordinary alto duet of "How Beautiful," which in my book is not Handel at his best. Clearly he thought so as well and replaced it with the beautiful soprano aria we know and love. So I think you get my drift! I hope it won’t spoil your enjoyment of our performances — my principal aim is bring out the drama and, above all, entertainment of this great work. Looking forward to meeting you sometime during the season.

All best,
Harry

Compliments to Harry

Harry Christophers:

I enjoyed the performance at Symphony Hall last Friday night. I am looking forward to the next performance on November 6, 2009.

-Ronald

Dear Ronald,

I am so pleased you enjoyed the performance and I am looking forward to meeting you sometime in the near future. Your support of Handel and Haydn is most appreciated.

As ever,
Harry

Welcome to a New Season

Dear Mr. Christophers,

How delighted we were to arrive in our favorite last row second balcony seats last night, having joked with the usher that our name was engraved on the seats to find that our name was, in fact, on the seats!! What a very nice welcoming touch.

I am inquiring about the possibility of including music by Charpentier, Lully and Carissimi in Handel and Haydn Society music, or are they just outside the birth date limits?

We loved last night's concert! Thank you. All the best to you in this new and wonderful season.

-Richard and Elinor

Dear Richard and Elinor,

Thank you so much for your lovely email. I am delighted you enjoyed the concert and, indeed, the personal touch. You will, no doubt, be pleased to know that we have some Charpentier planned for December 2010 and I would dearly like to programme some more French baroque. We need to find the right guest conductor for this but, rest assured, it is definitely on my list!

All best,
Harry